Bad Conversations
The least interesting part of the Reverend Lillian Daniel’s recent book, Defrocked: Good News from a Bad Pastor for a Better Church (2026), is the story of her, to use Daniel’s term, “defrocking.” Far more compelling are her reflections on what it means to be a “bad pastor” in the United Church of Christ.
What does it mean to be a bad pastor? Her answer: (in)gloriously human.
That happens to be Jean Calvin’s definition of the good pastor (bonus pastor). More on that another time. But if you’re curious, read—and prepare to be surprised by how Defrocked reads as a commentary on—Book IV of The Institutes of the Christian Religion (1559).
More interesting to me still are the responses of Daniel’s clergy despisers to Defrocked. It’s a bad conversation, indeed. Devoid of love, generosity, and forgiveness sans transaction, Daniel’s clergy despisers demand her silence to enforce her unending debasement and the complainant’s eternal victimhood. In so doing, they make a mockery of ordained ministry, which is inherently liberating rather than repressive.
Suspended
I imagine Daniel chose the word “defrocked” because it is the kind of dramatic word you use to sell books. The less sexy word the UCC uses is suspended. She was suspended for three months for having a brief sexual relationship with a member of the staff she oversaw as pastor of a large church in the Chicago suburbs.
Pastors in the UCC (and other denominations) are prohibited from having sexual relationships with their staff and parishioners. Such relationships are always wrong, irrespective of how appropriate they may be in other respects. For example, Pastor Daniel was single, and so was the adult male staff member. Moreover, their encounter was, by Daniel’s account, consensual (and yes, I think an adult staff member can consent to a sexual relationship with their supervisor). In this case, consent doesn’t redeem the encounter, reported eighteen months after it occurred.
And to be clear, I am in no way implying that the male staff member should not have made a complaint or that his complaint is improper because it came more than a year after his sexual encounter with Daniel.
Bad Stories
I was in a horrid mental state and physically incapacitated when I was sexually assaulted by a male professor. Years later, this same professor also physically assaulted me, slapping me so hard my head rang.
I respect the complainant’s choice to formally lodge a complaint. I didn’t. About a decade later, though, I did try to tell a school administrator about it. They insisted that I not talk about it.
I don’t regret not making a formal complaint. Because, to echo Martha Nussbaum, “to make one’s life all about a harm, since that is what protracted litigation [in my case, a Title IX complaint] would have done, seems to me a sacrifice that morality does not demand” (listen to her lecture, “Sexual Violence: Accountability in a Culture of Celebrity,” here).
Refusing Victimhood
Nussbaum anticipates at least one risk in sharing her experience of sexual violence that we should all consider before sharing our own stories of sexual assault. You will be psychologized and pathologized if you are a victim. “I was very lucky,” Nussbaum writes, “I have never experienced any sexual trauma from the episode, and to this day I think it has affected me almost not at all. . . .”
Nussbaum’s testimony will not be enough for the pious. They are experts at turning one’s no into a yes. I am thinking, especially, of one of the worst ethical failures in Christendom, published as a sanctified treatise on how boundaries betray us: Carter Heyward’s book When Boundaries Betray Us: Beyond Illusions of What Is Ethical in Therapy and Life (1993).
Like Nussbaum, I have not “experienced any sexual trauma from the episode” with my professor. I don’t consider myself a victim, either. A wronged party, yes—but not a victim.
I took action, especially after he physically assaulted me, and I moved on. I focused on earning my Ph.D. To that end, I removed him from as much of my ongoing academic life as possible.
I also don’t consider him a sexual predator. In any case, he’s dead now (and I admit to taking some satisfaction in that fact).
Not Sorry, Sorry
I never received an apology from him, though I was forced to apologize to his “wife” when I observed, very loudly and publicly, that they never had sex together. He never indicated, across what was two decades of knowing him, that he was even aware he had done anything that would merit an apology.
In contrast, Daniel is unambiguous throughout her book: she violated the Ordained Minister’s Code of the UCC and was wrong to do so. In my experience (including being a member of a committee that investigated a very complex case of sexual misconduct in the UCC and a pastor of a church beset by the sexual misconduct of a previous pastor), if pastors admit the former, that is no guarantee they will concede the latter.
Moreover, Daniel fully cooperated with the instructions of her tribunal (Daniel’s term, and one Calvin likes to use, but more accurately, a Committee on Ministry or COM). Even so, after Westminster John Knox dropped Daniel’s book—and without offering specific reasons as to why, further fanning the flames of gossip and suspicion—her decision to self-publish her testimony regarding events that happened thirteen years ago has provoked (un)serious scrutiny.
Kenji Kuramitsu on Unending “Accountability”
Kenji Kuramitsu, writing for Sojourners, generously acknowledges the good news in Defrocked, writing that “Daniel’s creative reflections on the wonders and travails of ministry have helped define the modern landscape of mainline Protestantism.” But he chooses to focus his review entirely on Daniel’s characterization of the church’s investigation of her sexual misconduct.
Kuramitsu’s assessment of Daniel’s reactions to the investigative process is not entirely wrong. Reverend Daniel is all the things one expects of a big church pastor when they are not in charge: defensive, self-righteous, and so on. However, Kuramitsu can take issue with Daniel’s behavior only because Daniel describes it in her book. Daniel, in my view, does not fail to notice the plank in her own eye.
Nor is she entirely wrong about the process. In many respects, it is unfair to the accused.
For example, Defrocked accurately describes what confidentiality means in these investigations: the accused may not speak, even as nearly everyone else speaks about the accused’s circumstances.
The pastor in question (PIQ) is banned from sharing their story—even as their congregation is aflame with conversation about them. One reason this happens is that the COM only has authority over an ordained minister. The COM, as Daniel notes, rules over an ordained minister’s standing (their authority to act as an ordained minister in the UCC).
In fact, as Daniel observes, church officials do most of the talking to congregations about their pastor’s alleged sexual misconduct—and they do so in a way that leaves many gaps or silences in the narrative.
That’s problematic because, as research shows, we read silence negatively (see, for example, NurtureShock, chapter 3, “Why White Parents Don’t Talk About Race” [2009]). In practice, enforced silence lets the gaps be filled by rumors and the grievances of parishioners who don’t like their pastor in the first place.
The (mostly implicit) argument underlying (un)serious objections to Defrocked is simple: anyone guilty of any variety of sexual misconduct should remain silent and under a pall of suspicion and contempt so long as they shall live.
For example, Kuramitsu takes issue with what he considers Daniel’s disdain for apologies, and its symptom: avoidance of consequences:
“Confessions,” Daniel writes in Defrocked, “are public shows that do no real spiritual good,” nothing but a “televangelistic, hand-wringing plea for mercy.” She is defiant: Publicly apologizing to those you have harmed is rooted in religious Puritanism and a voyeuristic demand for “tears, wretchedness.” On the one hand, Daniel laments “people who judge some people for nothing but then excuse the very colleagues who should have been punished.” On the other hand, she seems to wish to avoid the consequences for her own inappropriate behavior.
But at no point in the book does Daniel try to avoid consequences. Trying to understand the consequences she faces and raising legitimate concerns about their appropriateness to the specific misconduct is not avoidance. It’s participation in the process—and that’s exactly what is required of the accused.
Bad Theology: On (Transactional) Forgiveness
Kuramitsu is, however, right about Daniel’s view of forgiveness. There are good (theological) reasons to agree with her.
The first is that Paul, in his undisputed letters, uses the usual vocabulary of forgiveness (aphesis/aphiēmi) only once, when citing a Psalm (Rom 4:7). When speaking for himself, he prefers charizomai, to give grace rather than to offer forgiveness (e.g., 2 Cor 2:7).
Paul’s letters are not, of course, the whole of the New Testament, and forgiveness is mentioned in the Gospels and elsewhere. However, it doesn’t follow that all forms of forgiveness are ethically viable.
Martha Nussbaum analyzes forgiveness thoroughly in Anger and Forgiveness: Resentment, Generosity, Justice (2016), a book I highly recommend to anyone commenting on Defrocked. She argues that forgiveness is often “an elusive and usually temporary prize held out at the end of a traumatic and profoundly intrusive process of self-denigration . . . . The person who administers the process is controlling and relentless toward the penitent, an inquisitor of acts and desires—even if in the end forgiveness is given” (72).
Forgiveness of the transactional variety, the kind so tragically illustrated by Daniel’s second meeting with the COM, is a cover for the always ethically problematic emotion of anger, wedded as it is to the pitfalls of payback and status obsession (74). In other words, forgiveness often functions to 1) harm the wrongdoer, the harm inflicted justified by the fantasy that it will right the wrong done, and to 2) lower the wrongdoer’s status, situating the “sinner” as beneath the “righteous,” worthy of our contempt rather than our love and generosity.
Again, I agree with Nussbaum: “the organized church rarely forgives without a transaction” (76). However, she identifies an alternative to transactional forgiveness.
The alternative is what she calls “Transition-Anger” (TA), an emotion related to but different from the usual form of anger. Unlike usual anger, TA focuses on the future and the wrong (as opposed to the wrongdoer). We may think of it as forgiveness sans transaction. The goal of this kind of forgiveness is to restore the wrongdoer to society (which may entail some form of just containment, like removal from a congregation) rather than harm or debase them.
Eternal Debasement
The project of debasement takes center stage in Kuramitsu’s essay when he enlists a psychoanalyst, Andrea Celenza, to imply that Daniel is a psychopath. Perfectly illustrating the wiles of piety, Kuramitsu situates Celenza’s typology beside Daniel’s own denials, inviting us to infer she is a “psychopathic predator.”
Like the “super predator” of the 1990s, this kind of predator can’t stop eating meat (as opposed to the one-time meat eater or “the narcissistically needy” person).
And what is the basis for this diagnosis? Daniel refused eternal debasement.
It does not occur to Kuramitsu that the wrongdoer can be wrong (as Daniel is at pains to admit), and that aspects of the process for determining wrongdoing can also be wrong.
It may be an inconvenient truth for some, especially in the UCC, but Daniel was treated unfairly by her COM in at least two ways. First, allowing itself to entertain conduct unrelated to the complaint was a mistake. The COM also erred when it allowed itself to behave in a manner unbecoming of Jesus Messiah loyalists.
During her second meeting with them, provoked by her insistence on being told why she was being suspended for a longer period, even after she had done everything required of her (a legitimate question, if you ask me), “[s]omeone. . . yelled, ‘You’re not helping yourself; you are unfit, and you are lucky we are not terminating you!’ Which caused others to shout that I was not unfit and that they wanted me to know they had been ready to lift my suspension that day. The room then exploded, and people were hollering” (159).
Kuramitsu—and many of Daniel’s clergy despisers—decline to think critically about ecclesial bureaucracy. Perhaps they have never had the privilege of being at odds with it, or maybe they are naughty masochists.
How long must Daniel be considered wrong? Is she wrong without end? Kuramitsu doesn’t ask those questions.
Eternal Victimhood
The real substance, in my view, of Kuramitsu’s review comes at the end, when he asks very good questions about storytelling. We are cautioned by Kuramitsu that our stories are, in fact, not entirely ours to tell, especially if they include those “who have not chosen such visibility. Such writing requires judicious discernment so as not to risk reviolating consent. According to a September open letter signed by 145 [final count: 253] concerned clergy, Daniel’s book ‘fails to meet the guidelines for trauma-informed care.’”
Such a failure is not, of course, a violation of the Code—but more importantly, the male staff member did, in fact, choose visibility. That is what happens when you make a complaint known to the church.
Even worse than visibility, by complaining about sexual misconduct, the victim becomes incapable, even thirteen years later, of being anything other than a victim. In the eyes of clergy like Kuramitsu, Daniel is forever a predator, and the victim is an eternal one.
The Concerned Clergy
And victims make more victims. Consider what I can only describe as an embarrassing, pathetic letter signed by more than 250 concerned clergy opposed to the publication of Defrocked. Their objection is straightforward: the Reverend Lillian Daniel has dared to refuse eternal debasement.
Their letter encourages potential signers to “act from their ethical and spiritual obligations.” It even asks their signers not to avoid conflict by signing anonymously. “Covenant requires accountability,” they write, “and we are called to hold each other accountable.” However, “existing power dynamics and the fear of possible repercussions” require them to keep some clergy comments confidential (and 14 courageous signers signed anonymously).
The Specter of “Power”
By “existing power dynamics and the fear of possible repercussions,” they mean, presumably, Daniel’s position as Conference Minister (CM). But they overstate the power of the Conference Minister over clergy within their jurisdiction. Moreover, they neglect the role of the Associate Conference Minister (ACM), who, at least in my experience, initiates investigations of misconduct. So, while some among their number may feel fear, it doesn’t follow that their fear is justified.
Their point about power is more salient, however, when considering the relationship of CM to ACM. Yet, what about Defrocked makes us think Daniel is eager to discipline her colleagues for disagreeing with her? Our concerned clergy friends may be guilty of projection.
Propagating Victimhood
The letter descends further into absurdity. The deeply concerned clergy claim that we are all victims of Daniel’s sexual abuse. “Defrocked suggests some sort of redemption,” our concerned clergy write, “but doesn’t acknowledge that the story has more than one victim: the one with whom the author transgressed boundaries being the first; the congregation being served, the second; and the wider church being the third.”
I deny the charge entirely, and I resent the forced—as in unconsented to—imposition of the title “victim.” Moreover, whose redemption is really in question?
I suggest that it is Daniel’s redemption our concerned clergy do not want to accept, a fact made glaringly obvious by their comparison of the church to other workplaces where she would not be rehired, much less promoted (and they fail to ask whether being a Conference Minister is really a promotion), let alone redeemed by the blood of Christ.
No Question About It: It’s Transactional Forgiveness.
Tragically, there is too much to mock in this unfortunate piece of ministerial writing, including the melodramatic piety of our clergy friends and their faulting Daniel for 1) going public with her criticism of the process, 2) daring to call out ministerial mediocrity, 3) taking issue with her accurate, though admittedly sensational, use of the word “defrocked,” and 4) having the gall to think something is wrong with churches that make it impossible to get in the door on Sunday morning or that cancel worship for breakfast.
The only thing our over-earnest friends don’t take issue with is Daniel’s use of foul language! Come now, give a frock—she uses the word “shit” in Defrocked.
More serious is the fact that their sanctimonious letter is another chapter in a horrifying history of transactional forgiveness. Washing their hands of responsibility for their letter—including revealing the names of those who wrote it—they assert their belief “in redemption and reconciliation, but not without justice-making” and encourage the letter’s recipients to “do the work that is yours to do” (emphasis added).
What the frock?! I thought redemption and reconciliation are forms of justice-making—in fact, the only forms that matter to the church.
Daniel’s clergy despisers should just be honest. By justice-making, they mean: punish Daniel for doing what we do, not what we say.
Real Harm(s)
The missive of the deeply concerned clergy is likely to do far more harm to the church’s reputation than Daniel’s book—justifying, as it does, the widespread belief that clergy are petty, easily offended people inordinately loyal to ecclesial bureaucracy, even at the expense of honest and open debate.
Our clergy friends should read Laura Kipnis’s book, Unwanted Advances: Sexual Paranoia Comes to Campus (2017). Kipnis is, in my humble opinion, an insufferable human being, but her argument is sound: critiquing a process is not (sexual) misconduct.
Our precious clergy claim for themselves, and deny to Daniel, a practice that belongs to all ordained ministers: “Speak the truth, not using [their] position, power, or authority to exploit any person nor using [their] position for unwarranted personal financial gain.” The deeply concerned clerics have also failed both to “[u]se technology and social media responsibly” and to “[s]eek to know, understand and respect the diversity of opinions and people within the United Church of Christ, affirming that all settings of the UCC speak to the church and not for it.”
Which brings me to an alternative response to Defrocked, inspired by Kuramitsu’s essay.
The Freudian Character of Ordained Ministry
Taking issue with Daniel’s assessment of the complaint’s grammatical style, Kuramitsu misleadingly appeals to Freud, specifically to the concept of “afterwardsness.” I don’t think Freud’s understanding of trauma does Kuramitsu’s argument any favors.
Applying a developed Freudian view of the traumatic to Defrocked, neither the sexual encounter with Daniel nor even the memory of that encounter would constitute the traumatic event, at least not fully. The Freudian logic of the traumatic event would entail the specific ways both the sexual act and the memory of it interact with and ignite earlier, to use Laplanche’s term developed in New Foundations for Psychoanalysis (1987), “enigmatic signifiers.” Said signifiers are related to parental eros, precisely what the infant cannot cogitate (for an outline of the logic of trauma in Freud’s psychoanalysis, see Laplanche and Pontalis, “Trauma (Psychical),” in The Language of Psychoanalysis [1973], esp. 467).
“Parenting, like teaching [and pastoring],” writes psychoanalyst Adam Phillips, in The Life You Want (2026), “is also, then, giving something that you didn’t know you had to give, to somebody who you never quite know, and who never quite knows what he is receiving and transforming” (78).
The Freudian view of trauma doesn’t help Kuramitsu because it calls into question the traumatic significance of the complainant’s sexual encounter with Daniel. More relevant, I think, is Freud’s definition of pastoral work. Freud writes:
We do not seek to bring [the patient] relief by receiving him into the catholic, protestant or socialist community. We seek rather to enrich him from his own internal resources, by putting at the disposal of his ego those energies which, owing to repression, are inaccessibly confined in his unconscious, as well as those which his ego is obliged to squander in the fruitless task of maintaining these repressions. Such activity as this is pastoral work in the best sense of the words (The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, XX, The Question of Lay Analysis, “Postscript” [1927], 256).
“Freud, who conspicuously doesn’t mention Judaism (or Zionism),” Phillips observes in Becoming Freud: The Making of a Psychoanalyst (Jewish Lives) (2014), “certainly uses the idea of pastoral work in the most ironic of senses; the pastoral work of psychoanalysis is about liberating energies, allowing the individual access to his inner resources, irrespective, at least in the first instance, of their moral value” (159).
Pharmakon
The responses of Daniel’s clergy despisers to Defrocked illustrate why Freud uses the term “pastoral work” in “the most ironic of senses.” They want to maintain repression, not relieve it.
I have a habit of taking irony seriously, and I suggest that we take Freud’s idea of “pastoral work in the best sense of the words” seriously. We should encourage conversation, the medicine of psychoanalysis and, I think, of any ministry attuned to human beings, even (especially) bad ones.
Subscribe to Gay Thoughts
Discover more from Gay Thoughts
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

