Articles for category: Quick Thought

Yet another chapter in Andrew Sullivan's anti-trans story.

Why I Unsubscribed from Andrew Sullivan’s *The Weekly Dish*

Andrew Sullivan gets a few things right: public support for trans freedom has narrowed, and winning elections matters. But when you strip away his reasonable concessions, what remains is not political argument — it is projection. This post applies John Rawls's concept of public reason to Sullivan's anti-trans screeds and finds them wanting. Sullivan's fantasy of gay kids being forced to transition by evil doctors is not a basis for public policy. It is a private obsession dressed up as political commentary. And the real world keeps telling him so.

Hoshaw's version of Bingen's Creation of the Soul for a post on placental relations, theology, viability, and abortion.

Placental Relations: Theology, Viability, and Roe v. Wade

What if Roe v. Wade was wiser than either its defenders or its critics realized? In this post, I take an unconventional path through medieval theology, Peter Sloterdijk's philosophy of the placenta, and Hildegard of Bingen's vision of ensoulment to argue that the Roe Court's viability standard wasn't arbitrary legal improvisation — it was judicial wisdom rooted in a remarkably consistent convergence of theological tradition and modern medicine. Along the way, I make the case that consistent originalism actually leads to a more radical pro-choice conclusion than Roe ever did, and that Dobbs, for all its claims of constitutional fidelity, is just as extra-legal as the decision it overturned — only less honest about it.

June 11, 2025

twhoshaw

Art as Trash, Delight

Weird Delight

I am delighted by these weird, radically centered spaces where the things of the world no one wants gather and cannot (easily) be reached.